I have the same problem as Peter (March 2011). My MI2 timer rewinds to "1" when turning the knob to a higher number. After disassembling the MI2 timer, nothing seems out of place or broken. But when winding the timer, the main axle seems to slip on its large gear.
howtomendit.com for free repair help, information and advice.
Try fixfault.com to fix toasters.