I agree with making sure the rings weren't lined up. Did you hone the cylinder before reinstalling the rings? I'm guessing not. The rings actually 'wear in' to the cylinder wall and leave microscopic grooves. You need to remove those grooves with a cylinder hone.
If you did that, AND you made sure you didn't line up the rings, you probably need a set of rings. How old is the engine? I should think that the rings would be ok on a fairly new engine.
Scott
November 2007